(Updated through Week 15 of 2025 NFL season)
How consistency ratings work Using fantasy points determined by ESPN's standard scoring , the charts contained in this column rate players based upon how consistently reliable they have been during the 2023 through 2025 seasons, a span of 51 weeks' worth of games (18 weeks in 2023 and 2024 and 15 so far in 2025). For IDPs (individual defensive players), the scoring from our weekly rankings is used: solo tackle (1.5), assisted tackle (0.75), tackle for loss (2), sack (4), interception (5), forced fumble (4), fumble recovery (4), touchdown (6), safety (2), pass defended (1.5). To familiarize you with the terminology and column headers listed in the charts below:
Start%: The player's "start percentage," which shows how often he earned your start in an ESPN standard PPR (points per reception) league. This is his number of "starts" -- those defined below -- divided by his number of scheduled team games.
CR: The player's "consistency rating," which is calculated as his weekly standard deviation divided by his PPR fantasy points per game average. This is meant to identify the players who were most consistently close to their weekly averages. The lower the number, the more consistent the player. Again, lower numbers are better
nPPR%: The player's start percentage using non-PPR scoring, using ESPN's standard scoring settings without any points per reception.
FPTS/G: The player's average PPR fantasy points scored per game.
Start: The number of times that the player's point total in a given week was worthy of having had him active in an ESPN standard PPR league.
Star: The number of times the player's point total ranked among the best at his position.
Stiff: The number of times the player's point total ranked among the worst at his position, making almost any waiver-wire option a smarter choice.
These are the benchmarks for what constitutes a "start," "star" or "stiff" performance:
Consistency Ratings Benchmarks
QB
RB
WR
TE
K
D/ST
DL
LB
DB
Start
Top 10
Top 25
Top 25
Top 10
Top 10
Top 10
Top 20
Top 20
Top 20
Star
Top 2
Top 5
Top 5
Top 2
Top 2
Top 2
Top 4
Top 4
Top 4
Stiff
21st+
51st+
51st+
21st+
21st+
21st+
41st+
41st+
41st+
Sat: The number of times the player missed a game. Players are not charged "stiff" points for sitting out, nor does it impact their overall consistency rating (CR), but it hurts their overall start percentage.
Players must have a start rate of at least 20% in either standard PPR or non-PPR scoring, rank among the top 20 quarterbacks, tight ends or kickers, top 50 running backs or wide receivers, or top 40 defensive linemen, linebackers or defensive backs, in terms of total fantasy points at their position from 2023 to 2025, or are averaging at least 50 snaps per game, for inclusion in the chart. All defense/special teams are included regardless of whether they meet those minimums.
For Consistency Ratings from the 2025 season only, click here .
Quick click by position:
Quarterback (QB) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
66.7
0.440
66.7
23.0
32
13
7
0
60.4
0.423
60.4
20.5
29
6
6
2
60.4
0.471
60.4
21.6
29
5
8
4
42.9
0.649
42.9
17.8
6
1
2
3
41.7
0.393
41.7
18.1
20
6
8
0
41.7
0.432
41.7
18.1
20
4
14
0
37.5
0.400
37.5
18.5
18
4
5
2
37.5
0.492
37.5
17.3
18
2
14
4
37.5
0.568
37.5
18.7
18
6
10
9
35.5
0.508
35.5
16.5
11
3
13
0
35.5
0.573
35.5
19.6
11
2
5
7
33.3
0.465
33.3
16.4
16
2
15
3
32.3
0.433
32.3
18.6
10
4
6
0
31.3
0.425
31.3
17.0
15
3
12
2
31.3
0.556
31.3
18.0
15
2
8
11
29.2
0.529
29.2
14.4
14
1
20
3
29.2
0.623
29.2
18.2
14
5
9
16
29.2
0.772
29.2
13.0
14
1
19
7
29.0
0.491
29.0
16.9
9
2
5
4
25.0
0.562
25.0
16.7
12
2
9
8
25.0
0.577
25.0
14.6
12
3
18
6
25.0
0.711
25.0
15.4
12
3
15
16
20.8
0.547
20.8
15.4
10
2
15
5
18.8
0.555
18.8
17.4
9
1
9
18
14.6
0.692
14.6
12.2
7
3
23
5
7.1
0.523
7.1
10.2
1
0
9
0
0.0
0.000
0.0
6.3
0
0
1
0
Running Back (RB) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
85.4
0.447
79.2
18.4
41
15
2
0
79.2
0.567
75.0
20.1
38
16
0
2
75.0
0.495
79.2
16.3
36
11
3
0
75.0
0.516
66.7
16.4
36
11
0
5
72.9
0.507
75.0
17.9
35
9
0
6
70.8
0.613
62.5
18.6
34
12
4
6
68.8
0.526
68.8
16.3
33
10
0
1
66.7
0.571
64.6
23.0
32
16
0
14
66.7
0.587
66.7
17.8
32
11
0
4
62.5
0.576
50.0
13.8
30
6
2
2
62.5
0.622
54.2
15.1
30
10
4
1
60.4
0.531
56.3
13.2
29
4
3
2
60.4
0.548
64.6
13.9
29
4
1
6
60.4
0.643
64.6
19.0
29
11
0
10
58.3
0.623
52.1
15.8
28
6
1
10
58.1
0.589
51.6
14.9
18
3
2
7
57.1
0.597
50.0
13.7
8
3
0
0
57.1
0.793
42.9
12.8
8
3
1
0
50.0
0.556
43.8
12.0
24
4
4
1
50.0
0.570
50.0
12.6
24
4
5
1
50.0
0.649
50.0
16.0
7
2
0
6
47.9
0.494
45.8
12.3
23
3
0
1
47.9
0.499
39.6
10.8
23
1
3
3
47.9
0.631
41.7
15.3
23
6
2
16
47.9
0.641
43.8
12.2
23
4
7
4
47.9
0.693
45.8
12.1
23
5
8
6
46.2
0.568
46.2
12.3
6
1
2
0
45.8
0.756
47.9
10.5
22
4
10
2
43.8
0.597
37.5
12.3
21
1
4
10
43.8
0.619
43.8
16.4
21
8
1
17
43.8
0.627
45.8
13.1
21
2
3
8
42.9
0.754
50.0
9.7
6
0
2
0
41.9
0.688
35.5
10.3
13
2
5
2
41.7
0.651
39.6
11.1
20
1
4
11
41.7
0.740
43.8
9.6
20
2
10
5
38.6
0.618
47.7
9.7
17
1
7
2
37.5
0.702
41.7
11.1
18
3
5
10
35.7
0.649
42.9
11.5
5
2
1
0
35.7
0.793
42.9
8.6
5
1
5
0
33.3
0.801
29.2
8.8
16
1
12
4
31.3
0.575
29.2
13.3
15
2
0
24
31.3
0.652
25.0
11.8
15
3
1
20
31.3
1.028
31.3
9.4
15
4
12
9
28.6
0.676
21.4
14.2
4
1
1
7
27.1
0.724
29.2
10.7
13
2
4
16
27.1
0.861
25.0
7.4
13
1
17
2
25.0
0.721
18.8
8.9
12
1
4
9
25.0
0.786
31.3
9.0
12
1
8
2
22.9
0.655
25.0
9.0
11
0
4
18
22.9
0.736
27.1
7.4
11
1
12
0
22.6
1.166
22.6
4.7
7
0
21
0
21.4
0.882
28.6
5.7
3
0
7
0
21.4
0.934
28.6
7.6
3
1
4
0
20.8
1.009
29.2
6.4
10
2
18
5
18.8
0.887
16.7
7.4
9
1
15
7
18.8
0.942
20.8
7.0
9
2
15
1
12.5
0.716
10.4
5.5
6
0
14
2
8.3
0.662
14.6
6.7
4
0
9
10
Wide Receiver (WR) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
70.8
0.482
68.8
19.6
34
11
5
1
70.8
0.548
60.4
19.7
34
9
2
5
62.5
0.565
62.5
19.3
30
12
6
7
54.8
0.557
45.2
13.4
17
1
6
1
54.2
0.648
50.0
19.8
26
13
7
2
52.1
0.591
45.8
17.0
25
10
6
8
52.1
0.597
45.8
16.6
25
5
7
7
52.1
0.613
43.8
16.2
25
5
5
3
50.0
0.596
43.8
14.8
24
5
14
0
50.0
0.620
45.8
16.2
24
8
8
5
47.9
0.540
37.5
13.1
23
1
13
2
47.9
0.592
45.8
13.7
23
3
7
7
47.9
0.614
41.7
14.0
23
4
11
5
45.8
0.532
52.1
13.2
22
3
10
1
41.9
0.582
45.2
14.4
13
3
6
3
41.7
0.526
37.5
13.3
20
2
9
4
41.7
0.585
37.5
13.8
20
4
8
7
41.7
0.591
29.2
13.5
20
1
7
10
41.7
0.609
33.3
14.2
20
4
11
9
41.7
0.653
37.5
13.9
20
8
10
3
39.6
0.550
43.8
13.2
19
2
8
3
39.6
0.562
33.3
12.7
19
2
11
1
39.6
0.643
35.4
17.5
19
11
7
11
39.6
0.655
41.7
16.0
19
7
6
12
39.6
0.676
37.5
15.1
19
8
8
6
38.7
0.665
38.7
11.9
12
2
10
4
37.5
0.711
35.4
13.1
18
4
14
5
35.7
0.541
35.7
12.9
5
1
2
0
35.7
0.640
28.6
13.1
5
3
3
0
35.4
0.608
31.3
12.3
17
3
10
5
35.4
0.716
33.3
14.8
17
9
10
6
33.3
0.672
27.1
13.9
16
6
11
0
33.3
0.745
37.5
11.7
16
5
14
7
32.3
0.659
25.8
17.4
10
4
2
12
31.3
0.626
33.3
15.3
15
4
3
20
31.3
0.671
22.9
9.7
15
0
19
2
31.3
0.699
31.3
12.1
15
3
10
11
31.3
0.707
37.5
12.8
15
4
10
5
31.3
0.730
35.4
14.7
15
6
10
12
31.3
0.752
29.2
12.0
15
5
15
11
29.0
0.777
29.0
10.0
9
1
15
2
28.6
1.021
28.6
6.9
4
0
10
0
27.1
0.592
20.8
11.0
13
2
15
2
25.0
0.631
20.8
10.2
12
1
21
4
25.0
0.661
22.9
10.1
12
1
16
4
25.0
0.730
27.1
11.6
12
3
16
7
24.5
0.689
22.4
10.6
12
0
14
13
22.9
0.796
27.1
8.6
11
0
24
3
22.9
0.923
16.7
9.8
11
3
19
8
22.6
0.671
25.8
10.0
7
0
10
2
21.4
1.070
28.6
6.5
3
0
7
1
20.8
0.639
22.9
13.5
10
3
7
25
20.8
0.643
18.8
13.2
10
2
7
18
20.8
0.723
20.8
10.3
10
2
19
1
20.8
0.832
31.3
9.2
10
2
22
4
20.8
0.909
22.9
9.9
10
1
21
8
20.4
0.788
16.3
8.0
10
0
26
1
18.8
0.861
22.9
9.1
9
3
27
1
14.6
0.867
14.6
9.4
7
2
24
5
Tight End (TE) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
60.4
0.571
54.2
15.0
29
12
9
1
56.3
0.624
56.3
14.2
27
9
11
8
54.8
0.631
48.4
15.2
17
7
3
3
52.1
0.578
39.6
13.2
25
7
8
3
52.1
0.600
41.7
12.4
25
3
11
6
42.9
0.427
57.1
11.8
6
1
4
0
39.6
0.700
33.3
10.7
19
3
14
7
37.5
0.620
29.2
10.1
18
1
20
3
35.4
0.700
31.3
11.2
17
5
12
9
31.3
0.654
18.8
10.7
15
2
12
9
31.3
0.675
22.9
9.0
15
2
23
2
31.3
0.691
16.7
10.3
15
3
10
9
31.3
0.821
29.2
9.3
15
2
21
0
29.5
0.667
22.7
9.6
13
2
14
7
29.2
0.638
25.0
9.5
14
1
14
9
29.2
0.763
25.0
9.2
14
5
21
4
29.2
0.815
27.1
8.7
14
3
24
0
28.6
0.514
21.4
11.1
4
1
4
0
27.1
0.712
20.8
10.9
13
4
11
11
27.1
0.898
18.8
7.8
13
4
26
1
25.0
0.687
22.9
8.3
12
2
21
4
21.4
0.634
14.3
6.3
3
0
9
0
21.4
0.863
14.3
9.4
3
1
6
2
21.4
0.881
21.4
8.7
3
1
6
1
20.8
0.818
25.0
7.8
10
3
24
5
20.8
1.016
18.8
6.3
10
2
31
4
20.8
1.031
22.9
7.8
10
1
22
14
18.8
0.884
25.0
8.5
9
4
19
6
14.6
0.817
16.7
7.9
7
1
23
4
Kicker (K) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
54.2
0.488
54.2
11.0
26
8
4
0
50.0
0.494
50.0
9.9
24
8
9
0
47.9
0.582
47.9
10.2
23
7
7
7
47.9
0.611
47.9
9.1
23
6
13
0
45.8
0.502
45.8
9.7
22
6
7
0
42.9
0.494
42.9
8.4
6
1
4
0
41.9
0.616
41.9
8.3
18
3
9
4
38.7
0.582
38.7
9.1
12
3
5
4
38.7
0.616
38.7
7.9
12
5
11
0
37.5
0.550
37.5
8.8
18
6
9
0
37.5
0.595
37.5
8.0
18
3
13
0
35.5
0.395
35.5
9.0
11
2
6
0
33.3
0.607
33.3
7.8
16
3
17
3
31.3
0.575
31.3
7.9
15
6
13
2
31.3
0.610
31.3
8.1
15
4
11
4
31.3
0.631
31.3
7.9
15
6
17
0
31.3
0.654
31.3
8.9
15
4
9
14
30.0
0.651
30.0
7.8
3
0
2
4
29.8
0.623
29.8
7.6
14
3
12
4
29.2
0.649
29.2
7.7
14
2
13
1
29.2
0.657
29.2
7.9
14
2
19
5
29.0
0.736
29.0
7.3
9
2
11
6
28.6
0.517
28.6
8.6
4
1
4
0
27.5
0.678
27.5
6.8
11
1
13
6
27.1
0.675
27.1
6.9
13
1
20
0
26.7
0.578
26.7
7.6
4
0
3
3
25.0
0.680
25.0
7.5
12
2
9
13
24.4
0.671
24.4
6.5
11
1
20
1
22.9
0.649
22.9
6.7
11
2
18
1
22.9
0.704
22.9
7.8
11
2
10
11
22.9
0.745
22.9
7.4
11
2
14
11
21.4
0.739
21.4
6.3
3
0
6
0
20.8
0.641
20.8
7.9
10
3
8
14
Team Defense/Special Teams (D/ST) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
54.2
0.700
54.2
8.3
26
3
10
0
47.9
0.852
47.9
6.7
23
2
12
0
45.8
0.827
45.8
7.9
22
8
11
0
45.8
0.867
45.8
7.4
22
4
13
0
43.8
0.837
43.8
6.5
21
2
8
0
43.8
1.053
43.8
7.6
21
8
13
0
43.8
1.127
43.8
6.4
21
3
16
0
41.7
0.880
41.7
7.2
20
2
13
0
41.7
0.933
41.7
7.8
20
7
10
0
41.7
1.155
41.7
6.0
20
6
15
0
41.7
1.186
41.7
6.1
20
3
15
0
39.6
0.839
39.6
7.3
19
3
8
0
37.5
0.992
37.5
6.3
18
3
12
0
37.5
1.019
37.5
7.2
18
6
10
0
37.5
1.122
37.5
5.6
18
4
13
0
37.5
1.510
37.5
6.3
18
7
19
0
35.4
0.984
35.4
5.5
17
2
17
0
35.4
1.021
35.4
5.8
17
3
12
0
35.4
1.147
35.4
5.6
17
4
14
0
33.3
0.822
33.3
6.7
16
2
13
0
33.3
0.972
33.3
5.8
16
2
14
0
33.3
1.184
33.3
5.3
16
1
14
0
33.3
1.202
33.3
5.6
16
6
19
0
31.3
1.247
31.3
5.3
15
3
16
0
31.3
1.426
31.3
4.3
15
1
21
0
29.2
1.280
29.2
5.5
14
5
16
0
27.1
1.099
27.1
5.8
13
4
13
0
25.0
1.375
25.0
4.2
12
1
15
0
22.9
1.457
22.9
4.3
11
3
23
0
22.9
1.857
22.9
3.1
11
1
23
0
18.8
1.144
18.8
4.4
9
1
17
0
18.8
1.661
18.8
3.4
9
1
18
0
Defensive Lineman (DL) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
41.9
0.637
41.9
11.6
13
4
9
5
41.7
0.700
41.7
12.4
20
12
20
1
41.7
0.812
41.7
12.7
20
9
21
1
39.6
0.613
39.6
12.7
19
7
13
5
39.6
0.817
39.6
11.1
19
8
23
0
35.4
0.615
35.4
10.4
17
6
24
1
31.3
0.778
31.3
9.3
15
5
27
4
31.3
0.899
31.3
8.8
15
4
27
1
29.2
0.770
29.2
10.0
14
8
25
4
27.1
0.697
27.1
10.0
13
6
18
8
27.1
0.732
27.1
9.1
13
5
24
2
27.1
0.822
27.1
10.5
13
5
18
12
27.1
0.865
27.1
9.0
13
4
23
10
25.0
0.761
25.0
8.0
12
3
29
0
25.0
0.829
25.0
9.2
12
4
24
5
25.0
0.851
25.0
8.4
12
3
26
1
25.0
0.890
25.0
6.9
12
3
34
0
22.9
0.650
22.9
8.6
11
3
26
2
22.9
0.990
22.9
6.9
11
2
24
9
22.9
1.012
22.9
9.9
11
5
27
5
22.6
0.811
22.6
8.0
7
3
20
0
21.4
0.949
21.4
6.1
3
1
8
0
20.8
0.659
20.8
8.8
10
2
23
0
20.8
0.674
20.8
7.6
10
1
28
6
20.8
0.713
20.8
8.6
10
4
28
0
20.8
0.755
20.8
10.3
10
5
15
14
20.8
0.794
20.8
9.7
10
5
22
7
20.8
0.871
20.8
7.6
10
2
21
15
20.8
0.906
20.8
7.2
10
2
34
2
20.8
0.935
20.8
6.9
10
2
33
0
18.8
0.620
18.8
8.2
9
1
29
0
18.8
0.809
18.8
7.0
9
1
29
1
18.4
0.757
18.4
8.2
9
3
27
1
16.7
0.646
16.7
9.7
8
1
16
10
16.7
0.735
16.7
6.8
8
0
32
0
14.9
0.713
14.9
7.0
7
0
30
1
14.6
1.023
14.6
7.7
7
3
30
0
13.3
0.802
13.3
7.1
6
2
26
3
12.5
0.758
12.5
6.3
6
1
35
1
12.5
0.848
12.5
6.9
6
2
27
2
12.5
0.925
12.5
6.9
6
3
33
0
10.4
0.856
10.4
6.4
5
2
35
1
10.4
0.939
10.4
6.6
5
3
33
3
8.3
0.900
8.3
7.1
4
3
30
3
Linebacker (LB) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
54.2
0.497
54.2
14.1
26
10
12
1
50.0
0.366
50.0
12.5
7
1
1
0
50.0
0.391
50.0
13.4
24
8
8
0
50.0
0.486
50.0
13.7
24
5
10
4
50.0
0.511
50.0
13.6
24
11
13
1
46.8
0.494
46.8
13.2
22
3
8
4
45.8
0.530
45.8
13.3
22
5
11
4
43.8
0.476
43.8
12.9
21
9
12
1
43.8
0.498
43.8
12.7
21
6
10
5
43.8
0.516
43.8
13.0
21
7
11
2
41.7
0.463
41.7
12.0
20
4
16
1
41.7
0.546
41.7
12.8
20
4
13
4
39.6
0.403
39.6
12.2
19
5
12
0
38.9
0.531
38.9
13.1
14
3
7
6
37.5
0.554
37.5
12.0
18
5
11
9
37.5
0.633
37.5
13.1
18
8
11
8
37.5
0.646
37.5
12.4
18
7
12
10
35.7
0.558
35.7
10.6
5
1
6
0
35.4
0.416
35.4
11.4
17
2
10
0
35.4
0.539
35.4
11.6
17
4
15
1
35.4
0.545
35.4
10.8
17
2
16
5
35.4
0.603
35.4
10.7
17
6
20
0
33.3
0.505
33.3
10.5
16
4
18
0
33.3
0.554
33.3
12.6
16
5
11
7
32.3
0.805
32.3
9.9
10
3
9
10
31.3
0.525
31.3
11.4
15
3
12
6
31.3
0.556
31.3
11.8
15
3
13
6
31.3
0.593
31.3
10.9
15
4
16
5
31.3
0.652
31.3
10.2
15
3
17
1
31.3
0.683
31.3
9.7
15
3
21
4
31.3
0.756
31.3
10.3
15
9
20
1
29.2
0.576
29.2
10.7
14
3
14
8
29.2
0.602
29.2
12.6
14
5
10
8
29.2
0.744
29.2
9.2
14
6
23
0
29.0
0.563
29.0
10.8
9
4
8
3
28.6
0.722
28.6
7.6
4
1
8
0
27.1
0.620
27.1
12.2
13
4
7
19
26.1
0.685
26.1
10.6
12
3
14
11
25.0
0.552
25.0
12.8
12
2
4
15
25.0
0.561
25.0
11.6
12
5
10
10
25.0
0.607
25.0
13.4
12
4
7
24
25.0
0.637
25.0
10.0
12
4
19
5
22.9
0.597
22.9
10.0
11
1
20
4
21.4
0.941
21.4
6.7
3
0
8
3
20.8
0.581
20.8
10.4
10
1
14
7
20.8
0.655
20.8
10.7
10
2
15
17
20.8
0.910
20.8
7.7
10
3
27
2
18.8
0.541
18.8
8.8
9
0
25
5
16.7
0.565
16.7
8.9
8
2
25
2
16.7
0.624
16.7
8.6
8
3
22
2
Defensive Back (DB) Consistency Ratings Player
Start%
CR
nPPR%
FPTS/G
Start
Star
Stiff
Sat
37.5
0.606
37.5
11.6
18
7
24
5
35.4
0.604
35.4
12.3
17
5
17
8
33.3
0.586
33.3
11.5
16
9
25
0
29.0
0.683
29.0
10.3
9
4
12
5
28.6
0.655
28.6
11.0
4
2
5
3
25.5
0.491
25.5
10.9
12
5
25
0
25.0
0.488
25.0
11.2
12
3
23
5
25.0
0.663
25.0
11.3
12
5
23
3
22.9
0.486
22.9
9.6
11
3
27
1
22.9
0.547
22.9
10.0
11
3
28
2
22.9
0.561
22.9
9.5
11
1
27
4
22.9
0.563
22.9
10.9
11
7
25
2
22.9
0.709
22.9
8.5
11
2
28
0
22.9
0.763
22.9
8.4
11
4
30
2
20.8
0.461
20.8
10.3
10
3
27
0
20.8
0.473
20.8
10.2
10
1
28
0
20.8
0.528
20.8
8.7
10
2
33
0
20.8
0.610
20.8
9.1
10
2
27
5
20.8
0.622
20.8
8.8
10
3
33
0
20.8
0.626
20.8
8.7
10
2
31
3
20.8
0.657
20.8
10.7
10
6
22
9
20.8
0.659
20.8
10.3
10
2
26
8
20.8
0.720
20.8
10.5
10
5
21
12
20.8
0.752
20.8
9.6
10
3
28
6
18.8
0.579
18.8
9.6
9
3
30
5
18.8
0.772
18.8
8.4
9
4
30
5
16.7
0.417
16.7
9.6
8
1
30
0
16.7
0.566
16.7
8.5
8
0
31
4
16.7
0.600
16.7
9.4
8
2
23
10
16.7
0.619
16.7
9.1
8
2
31
4
16.7
0.627
16.7
10.4
8
2
17
13
16.7
0.629
16.7
9.7
8
2
27
10
16.7
0.652
16.7
11.8
8
4
16
17
16.7
0.810
16.7
8.1
8
4
31
1
16.3
0.766
16.3
8.4
8
3
28
6
16.1
0.492
16.1
8.5
5
2
22
0
14.6
0.523
14.6
9.6
7
1
23
7
14.6
0.553
14.6
8.7
7
1
31
5
14.6
0.615
14.6
8.6
7
4
33
3
12.5
0.606
12.5
8.2
6
1
32
6
12.5
0.628
12.5
7.9
6
2
32
2
12.5
0.633
12.5
7.4
6
0
35
1
10.4
0.538
10.4
9.0
5
2
31
0
10.4
0.634
10.4
9.0
5
2
27
8
10.4
0.683
10.4
8.6
5
1
33
3
10.4
0.830
10.4
7.1
5
3
35
2
8.3
0.540
8.3
7.6
4
0
37
1
6.5
0.654
6.5
6.9
2
1
26
0
6.3
0.678
6.3
6.9
3
1
37
4
4.2
0.648
4.2
6.2
2
0
39
2
4.2
0.701
4.2
6.0
2
0
41
1
3.2
0.664
3.2
5.3
1
0
27
1
